Movies Like To All the Boys I've Loved Before for Your Next Cozy Crush Fix
Sweet teen romances with secret crushes, fake-dating schemes, and butterflies that feel real.
Sweet teen romances with secret crushes, fake-dating schemes, and butterflies that feel real.
Best first watch
The Perfect Date (2019)
93% fit90 min · IMDb 5.8 · RT 67%
Brooks Rattigan's fake-boyfriend-for-hire app mirrors Lara Jean's fake relationship with Peter Kavinsky, and Noah Centineo plays both roles with the same easygoing charisma. Chris Nelson keeps the pace snappy at 90 minutes, leaning into the absurdity of Brooks becoming whoever his clients need. The payoff lands the same way: the act crumbles, real feelings rush in.
Watch if
You loved Peter Kavinsky and want more Noah Centineo charm.
Skip if
You find fake-dating plots too predictable to enjoy.
For you if
- You want sweet, butterflies-in-your-stomach romance without heavy drama.
- You enjoy fake-dating setups and secret-crush reveals.
- You love watching teens stumble through first relationships with genuine heart.
Not for you if
- You want explicit or steamy adult romance.
- You prefer cynical, anti-love stories.
- You need action, thriller elements, or high stakes beyond the emotional kind.
How To All the Boys I've Loved Before (2018) alternatives compare
Pick The Perfect Date for a breezy Noah Centineo double feature that keeps the energy light. Love, Simon delivers the biggest emotional punch if you want to feel something deeper. Always Be My Maybe is the funniest of the group, with Ali Wong and Randall Park trading sharp one-liners. Hello, Goodbye, and Everything in Between is your best bet for a quick weeknight watch at just 83 minutes.
How sweet is it?
Sugar rush
How much will I laugh?
Plenty of laughs
Will it make me cry?
Dry eyes guaranteed
How fast does it move?
Breezy and quick
How sweet is it?
Full butterflies
How much will I laugh?
Funny moments
Will it make me cry?
Bring tissues
How fast does it move?
Steady build
How sweet is it?
Sweet with cringe
How much will I laugh?
Awkward comedy
Will it make me cry?
A few pangs
How fast does it move?
Takes its time
How sweet is it?
Bittersweet
How much will I laugh?
More smiles than laughs
Will it make me cry?
Lump in throat
How fast does it move?
Shortest and fastest
How sweet is it?
Warm and witty
How much will I laugh?
Laugh-out-loud funny
Will it make me cry?
Light tugs
How fast does it move?
Easy cruise
Not sure what to watch?
Date night
Grown-up romance with sharp comedy that works whether you're new together or longtime partners.
Quick watch
Hello, Goodbye, and Everything in Between (2022)
At 83 minutes, it's the fastest of the group and wraps up with a clean, satisfying ending.
Friend group
Light, funny, and easy to talk over without missing key plot points along the way.
Find your pick
Are you in the mood for a romance set in the hallways and house parties of high school?
Moments you loved
Best movies like To All the Boys I've Loved Before (2018)
1. The Perfect Date (2019)
90 min · IMDb 5.8 · RT 67%
Brooks Rattigan's fake-boyfriend-for-hire app mirrors Lara Jean's fake relationship with Peter Kavinsky, and Noah Centineo plays both roles with the same easygoing charisma. Chris Nelson keeps the pace snappy at 90 minutes, leaning into the absurdity of Brooks becoming whoever his clients need. The payoff lands the same way: the act crumbles, real feelings rush in.
Watch if
You loved Peter Kavinsky and want more Noah Centineo charm.
Skip if
You find fake-dating plots too predictable to enjoy.
Where to watch
2. Love, Simon (2018)
110 min · IMDb 7.5 · RT 92%
Where Lara Jean hides love letters in her closet, Simon hides his identity while falling for an anonymous classmate online. Greg Berlanti directs with the same warm glow of supportive parents and loyal friend circles. The secret at the center carries higher personal stakes, and Nick Robinson's performance gives the familiar teen-romance arc a deeper emotional pull.
Watch if
You want a teen love story with real emotional depth.
Skip if
You prefer pure comedy over heartfelt coming-of-age drama.
Where to watch
3. Sierra Burgess Is a Loser (2018)
105 min · IMDb 5.7 · RT 58%
Shannon Purser's Sierra texts Noah Centineo's Jamey while pretending to be someone else, creating the same 'when will the truth come out?' tension that fuels Lara Jean's exposed letters. Both films turn on a deception that starts innocent and spirals. Ian Samuels leans harder into underdog awkwardness, giving Sierra a rougher, less polished charm.
Watch if
You enjoy cringe comedy built on mistaken identity and texting mishaps.
Skip if
You need to fully root for the main character throughout.
Where to watch
4. Hello, Goodbye, and Everything in Between (2022)
83 min · IMDb 5.2 · RT 32%
Clare and Aidan's pact to break up before college echoes Lara Jean's contract with Peter: both couples set rules to avoid heartbreak and then break every one. At just 83 minutes, Michael Lewen keeps things tight. Jordan Fisher and Talia Ryder sell the will-they-won't-they through one emotionally loaded final date.
Watch if
You want a quick, bittersweet romance you can finish tonight.
Skip if
You prefer watching a relationship begin rather than potentially end.
Where to watch
5. Always Be My Maybe (2019)
102 min · IMDb 6.7 · RT 89%
Ali Wong's Sasha and Randall Park's Marcus carry the same unspoken-crush energy as Lara Jean's secret letters, stretched over fifteen years instead of high school semesters. Nahnatchka Khan sharpens the comedy with culturally specific family dynamics and a legendary Keanu Reeves cameo. It proves the fake-it-till-you-feel-it formula works at any age.
Watch if
You want the teen crush formula with adult humor and sharper wit.
Skip if
You are specifically looking for a high school setting.
Where to watch
Beyond movies
TV shows and books that scratch the same itch
Never Have I Ever
Mindy Kaling's writing delivers the sharp, self-aware humor that defines this hub, while Devi's overlapping crushes and impulsive romantic schemes mirror the secret-feelings and fake-relationship energy of To All the Boys.
Netflix
XO, Kitty
A direct spinoff from the To All the Boys universe, it keeps the sweet crush-driven plotting and letter-writing romanticism while adding a K-drama twist, all wrapped in witty, cringe-free dialogue.
Netflix
Heartstopper
Earnest first-love butterflies told with gentle humor and zero melodrama. Its warm, hopeful tone and secret-crush storylines land in the same emotional space as Lara Jean's hidden love letters.
Netflix
The Sun Is Also a Star
by Nicola Yoon
A whip-smart, tightly structured one-day romance between two teens who keep surprising each other. Its playful narration and genuine emotional stakes match the warm, clever tone of Lara Jean's story.
Available at major bookstores
Common questions about movies like To All the Boys I've Loved Before (2018)
What is the best movie like To All the Boys I've Loved Before (2018)?
Based on our analysis, The Perfect Date (2019) is the closest match with a 93% fit score. See the full breakdown above for why it earned the top spot.
Can I watch all of these with my younger teen?
All five keep the romance sweet and teen-appropriate. Love, Simon explores coming out with sensitivity, which could spark a great conversation. Always Be My Maybe, with Ali Wong and Randall Park, skews slightly older in its humor.
Do any of these get into heavy or uncomfortable territory?
Love, Simon carries the weight of hiding your identity from family and friends, which can feel intense even in a warm package. Sierra Burgess involves catfishing behavior that some viewers find frustrating rather than endearing. The other three stick to lighter relationship stakes.
Which one will leave me feeling the happiest?
The Perfect Date ends on a pure feel-good high with zero emotional baggage. Always Be My Maybe wraps up warm, with Ali Wong and Randall Park's chemistry landing a satisfying final beat. Both are safe bets for ending your night smiling.
Which is the quickest watch for a weeknight?
Hello, Goodbye, and Everything in Between runs just 83 minutes, making it the easiest to fit into a busy evening. The Perfect Date is next at 90 minutes and moves at a snappy clip. Both get in, tell their story, and get out.
Which is the funniest and which hits hardest emotionally?
Always Be My Maybe gets the biggest laughs, especially a legendary Keanu Reeves cameo that catches you completely off guard. Love, Simon hits hardest emotionally, particularly Nick Robinson's scenes with Jennifer Garner as his mom. The Perfect Date splits the difference between silly and sweet.
Which should I watch first if I loved To All the Boys?
Start with The Perfect Date. It shares Noah Centineo as the lead and the same fake-dating DNA. From there, Love, Simon is the natural next step for something with more emotional weight. Save Always Be My Maybe for when you want the formula with an adult twist.
Was this list useful?
Quick feedback helps us improve ranking quality.