Movies Like A Haunting in Venice for spooky mansion chills and tidy detective payoffs
Spooky mansion mysteries with séance tension, stormy rooms, and tidy detective payoffs.
Spooky mansion mysteries with séance tension, stormy rooms, and tidy detective payoffs.
Best first watch
Crooked House (2017)
94% fit115 min · IMDb 6.3 · RT 57%
Like the seed film, this locks you inside a grand old house where every room hides a fresh lie. Gilles Paquet-Brenner keeps the mystery moving through sharp family clashes, a spooky estate mood, and detective work from Charles Hayward and Chief Inspector Taverner. The payoff is tidy and satisfying, with just enough dark tension for a low-stress night.
Watch if
Watch if you want stormy rooms, nasty relatives, and a clean detective reveal.
Skip if
Skip if family poison and cold-blooded mansion secrets sound too sour.
For you if
- You want spooky whodunits that stay cozy instead of brutal.
- You enjoy old houses, candlelight, séances, and suspects with polished manners.
- You like clear detective work with a little supernatural doubt in the air.
Not for you if
- You want harsh horror, graphic scares, or nonstop dread.
- You prefer broad comedy and a much lighter, jokier mood.
- You need action-heavy thrillers with chases, fights, and loud set pieces.
How A Haunting in Venice (2023) alternatives compare
Pick Crooked House if you want the closest match to spooky mansion mystery and the sharpest final reveal. Pick Enola Holmes 2 for a lighter date-night vibe and more movement. Agatha and the Truth of Murder works best when you want quieter period sleuthing. Either Sparkling Cyanide is good for a polished poison-case watch, with the 1983 film feeling brisker and the 2003 version feeling sleeker.
Spooky house feeling
Eerie estate
Detective payoff
Knife-clean solve
Breezy date-night mood
Cozy, slightly sharp
Suspect-circle fun
Packed suspect maze
Spooky house feeling
Barely spooky
Detective payoff
Busy but neat
Breezy date-night mood
Bright and playful
Suspect-circle fun
Many moving parts
Spooky house feeling
Wintry chill
Detective payoff
Steady closure
Breezy date-night mood
Gentle but sad
Suspect-circle fun
Focused interviews
Spooky house feeling
Sleek indoors
Detective payoff
Polished wrap-up
Breezy date-night mood
Easy evening watch
Suspect-circle fun
Social web
Spooky house feeling
Dinner tension
Detective payoff
Classic reveal
Breezy date-night mood
Pleasantly pulpy
Suspect-circle fun
Dinner-party suspects
Not ready to choose? Save these Cozy Mystery Night picks for later
Add all 5 to your watchlist in one tap — no account needed to start.
Not sure what to watch?
Date night
Spooky estate rooms and a clean reveal give you Halloween mood without pushing into heavy horror.
Quick watch
Agatha and the Truth of Murder (2018)
At just over ninety minutes, it delivers period detective comfort without asking for a whole evening.
Friend group
The lively banter, bigger set pieces, and easy clues make it the safest crowd-pleaser for mixed tastes.
Find your pick
Do you want a brisk, playful detective story with a young heroine and a few light action beats?
Moments you loved
Best movies like A Haunting in Venice (2023)
1. Crooked House (2017)
115 min · IMDb 6.3 · RT 57%
Like the seed film, this locks you inside a grand old house where every room hides a fresh lie. Gilles Paquet-Brenner keeps the mystery moving through sharp family clashes, a spooky estate mood, and detective work from Charles Hayward and Chief Inspector Taverner. The payoff is tidy and satisfying, with just enough dark tension for a low-stress night.
Watch if
Watch if you want stormy rooms, nasty relatives, and a clean detective reveal.
Skip if
Skip if family poison and cold-blooded mansion secrets sound too sour.
Where to watch
2. Enola Holmes 2 (2022)
129 min · IMDb 6.8 · RT 93%
This trades séance tension and spooky rooms for brisk clues, street-level chases, and a warmer detective mood. Harry Bradbeer keeps the mystery light on its feet, with Enola's direct address and sibling teamwork giving the case a playful rhythm. You still get tidy payoffs, hidden motives, and cozy whodunit pleasure without much horror.
Watch if
Watch if you want tidy detective payoffs with lively banter instead of stormy dread.
Skip if
Skip if you need a mansion setting and spooky séance-style tension.
Where to watch
3. Agatha and the Truth of Murder (2018)
93 min · IMDb 6.3
Like the seed film, this builds its mystery around grief, suspicion, and people performing versions of themselves in closed rooms. Terry Loane favors a steadier pace, letting Agatha question suspects and peel back motives one layer at a time. The feeling is more wintry than spooky, but the detective trail and tidy payoff fit a cozy mystery night.
Watch if
Watch if you like softer suspense, period rooms, and a tidy detective trail.
Skip if
Skip if you want stormy mansion chills or stronger séance tension.
4. Sparkling Cyanide (2003)
120 min · IMDb 5.9
This one drops the haunted-house feeling and leans into glamorous London rooms, a poison death, and a wide suspect web. Tristram Powell gives the case a polished TV-mystery pace, with investigators moving from socialite gossip to higher-level secrets. The draw is the same tidy detective payoff, with enough tension to stay interesting and still feel easygoing.
Watch if
Watch if you enjoy elegant rooms, poison clues, and a tidy detective ending.
Skip if
Skip if you want spooky mansion shadows or séance-flavored mystery.
Where to watch
5. Sparkling Cyanide (1983)
100 min · IMDb 5.9
Like the seed film, this starts with a gathering that turns deadly, then traps everyone inside a tight circle of motives. Robert Michael Lewis keeps the structure simple and brisk, moving from dinner-table suspicion to room-by-room questioning. It is less spooky than the palazzo mystery, but the detective unraveling and neat payoff scratch the same comfort-watch itch.
Watch if
Watch if you want a brisk old-school detective mystery with tense dinner-room suspicion.
Skip if
Skip if you need stormy rooms, séance tension, or a richer house mood.
Where to watch
Beyond movies
TV shows and books that scratch the same itch
Miss Fisher's Murder Mysteries
This series lives squarely in cozy mystery territory, with elegant houses, sly humor, and clean case-of-the-week reveals. It matches the seed movie's love of locked-room style puzzles, glamorous period settings, and a detective who cuts through eerie rumors with style.
Available for purchase on Prime Video and Apple TV+ and Google Play and Fandango
Father Brown
It is a comfort-watch whodunit built around tidy solutions, village secrets, and a warm rhythm that keeps the suspense light. Several episodes lean into haunted houses, spiritual frauds, and closed-circle suspects, which lines up well with the séance and spooky manor appeal of A Haunting in Venice.
Available for purchase on Prime Video and Apple TV+ and Google Play and Fandango
Jonathan Creek
This is a cozy mystery favorite that turns impossible crimes and creepy setups into playful detective puzzles. Its gothic houses, stormy-night mood, and rational explanations for seemingly supernatural events echo the seed movie's spooky-but-solvable fun.
BritBox
Hallowe'en Party
by Agatha Christie
Its Hallowe'en setting, uneasy party atmosphere, and a child's claim of having seen a murder give it the same cozy-spooky pull as A Haunting in Venice. Poirot brings the kind of clean, satisfying solution that suits a low-stress mystery night.
Available at major bookstores
Common questions about movies like A Haunting in Venice (2023)
What is the best movie like A Haunting in Venice (2023)?
Based on our analysis, Crooked House (2017) is the closest match with a 94% fit score. See the full breakdown above for why it earned the top spot.
Which of these works best with someone who usually avoids horror?
Enola Holmes 2 is the easiest bridge because its detective story stays playful and busy. Crooked House has the strongest spooky-house feeling, but it is still a mystery first. The two Sparkling Cyanide films are good for viewers who like murder puzzles and zero ghost talk.
Which one should I skip if poison deaths or nasty family behavior bother me?
Crooked House is the sharpest on cruel relatives and ugly motives, so that one can leave the chilliest aftertaste. Both Sparkling Cyanide films center on a poison death and layers of adultery and betrayal. Enola Holmes 2 is the gentlest on that front.
What should I watch if I want the most upbeat ending to the night?
Go with Enola Holmes 2. The case still has stakes, yet Millie Bobby Brown and Henry Cavill keep the mood lively, and the story ends with a bright sense of momentum. Agatha and the Truth of Murder is more reflective.
Which is the easiest weeknight pick when I do not want a long, dense case?
Agatha and the Truth of Murder is the shortest and the least busy, so it fits a tired weeknight well. Sparkling Cyanide from 1983 is also brisk and straightforward. Enola Holmes 2 asks for the most attention because it juggles the most plot threads.
Which one feels darkest, and which feels breeziest?
Crooked House feels darkest because the family itself is the source of the chill, and the estate keeps that closed-room pressure on. Enola Holmes 2 is breeziest thanks to its humor, movement, and sibling banter. The two Sparkling Cyanide versions sit in the middle with polished TV-mystery ease.
Where should I start if I want the closest match to spooky mansion detective vibes?
Start with Crooked House. It gives you the grand-house setting, a crowded suspect list, and a clean detective finish that lines up best with a fall mystery night. If you want something lighter after that, move to Enola Holmes 2.
Was this list useful?
Quick feedback helps us improve ranking quality.